Separation Blame for a Single Episode of Violence: Legal Implications

The Court of Cassation (Cassazione) recently ruled that both physical and moral violence by one spouse constitute such severe violations of marital duties that they can lead not only to a separation but also to the attribution of blame. The court held that these actions are so grave that they make living together intolerable, relieving the judge from the obligation to compare them with the potential behavior of the spouse who is the victim of the violence.

In a case before the Macerata Tribunal, the Cassation Court overturned the decision of the Catania Court of Appeal, which had upheld the lower court’s rejection of mutual blame claims by the spouses. The wife had accused her husband of violent conduct, but the Court of Appeal found the evidence insufficient.

The Cassation Court, however, sided with the wife, emphasizing that even a single episode of physical violence is sufficient to establish blame. It reiterated that violent behavior, due to its extreme gravity, does not require comparison with the victim’s behavior and that the temporal sequence of violence concerning the marital crisis is irrelevant.

This ruling aligns with previous judgments, emphasizing that a single violent episode can irreversibly disrupt the couple’s balance and dignity. The Court highlighted that the temporal proximity of the violent act to the marital crisis does not justify it as a subsequent reaction to the passive party’s behavior.

This decision reinforces the legal stance that violent actions, regardless of their temporal sequence, can result in separation blame, providing legal clarity on the severe consequences of spousal violence in Italian family law.

VGS Lawyers is a law firm specialised in Family Law. Should you need assistance please  send your enquiry to: info@vgslawyers.com